I wish I knew the inside story on Google's recent confrontation with the Chinese government. At first Google's announcement looked like a principled, well thought-out stand in a long behind-the-scenes dispute (link). But as more details have emerged, it has started to look as if Google didn't think through the consequences outside of its core search business. In the mobile market, those consequences could be significant. Here's why...
Google's Android OS has been gaining enormous support among mobile operators and handset vendors because it was viewed as the most feasible alternative to total domination by Apple. All of the other OS options had nasty baggage -- Microsoft was viewed as both controlling and unable to create demand, Symbian was seen as Nokia's pet, and the other flavors of Linux were all below critical mass.
In contrast, Google seemed technically competent, vendor-neutral, and capable of attracting users. (By the way, it says something about Apple's growing power in the mobile industry that a company as controlling as Google was seen as the safe partner; it's kind of like cozying up to a kodiak bear to escape a tiger.)
Google's dispute in China damages its image as a safe partner. A phone announcement in China involving Motorola, Samsung, and China Unicom has now been delayed because of the dispute, and it's not clear when it will be rescheduled. The public story on the delay is that Google demanded it (link), but I'm not sure I believe that. China Unicom is basically owned by the Chinese government, and I wouldn't be surprised if the delay was forced by them as a way to punish Google.
Either way, picture how this must feel to Motorola and Samsung. They have nothing to do with the dispute, but now they're trapped between Google and the Chinese government. That wouldn't be a big deal if we were talking about, say, the Cambodian phone market (no offense, Cambodia), but Samsung and Motorola both view China as a critical growth market. They can't afford to be pushed out of it.
Even aside from the political fears, real economic damage has already been done. Google's actions have delayed the imminent release of some major licensees' devices. Unless you have worked in a handset company, it's hard to understand how utterly unacceptable that is to them. Product launches are planned many months in advance, and are coordinated down to the day. Samsung and Motorola both have phone inventory waiting to be sold. There's cash tied up in that inventory, salespeople can't make their quotas, advertising was probably planned that now has to be rescheduled at additional cost, and so on. Plus, both companies now lose ground to competitors selling other devices. Most phones have a short lifetime anyway, so sales lost now probably can't be made up later. If you were a Motorola employee and you caused that sort of disruption, you'd probably get fired. But Motorola can't fire its OS supplier.
At least not immediately.
Because of problems like this, Google is now talking hopefully about retaining its business unit in China even if it closes down its search engine there (link). That raises the question of why Google threatened to completely pull out of China in the first place. If I were an official in the Chinese government, I'd view this flip-flop as a sign of vulnerability, and would be tempted to systematically go after targets like Android in an effort to put more pressure on Google. But for the moment the government appears to be moving cautiously, perhaps to avoid creating sympathy for Google.
Maybe in a week Google and the Chinese government will have come up with a neat, face-saving resolution to the whole problem. But even in that best-case scenario, Google's image as a supplier to the mobile industry has been damaged. The company has shown that its search business is more important to it (and more top-of-mind) than its mobile OS. Mobile operators outside of China won't care about this, but the handset vendors will. Some of them are based in China, and almost all manufacture there and sell into that market. Who's to say that Google won't end up in another dispute in China in another year? Add in Google's decision to start making its own phones in competition with licensees, and it now looks like a much less reliable OS supplier than it was six months ago.
To a Chinese phone company, relying on Android must now feel extremely uncomfortable. I bet Samsung went ballistic in private; it is completely intolerant of a supplier who's interested in anything other than making Samsung rich. I'd expect Samsung to put more emphasis on its other OS options in the future. And somewhere at Motorola, a harried executive is probably rolling his or her eyes and starting work on evaluating alternative smartphone operating systems, yet again.
The question is what alternative they'd choose. There's speculation that the LiMO alliance may be strengthened (link), and I could picture Chinese officials eventually trying to create a home-grown OS standard, just as they did in 3G (link). But the most straightforward alternative is Symbian, and I suspect it may get a quiet second look in many places -- although for the handset companies, that would feel like fleeing a tiger and a bear in order to hug an anaconda.
Home »
Android »
China »
google »
motorola »
Samsung »
symbian »
Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile
Wednesday, January 20, 2010
You've finished reading an article Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile and many articles about gadget in our blog this, please read it. and url link of this article is http://mallcopwarrior.blogspot.com/2010/01/google-shoots-itself-in-foot-in-mobile.html Hopefully discussion articles on could provide more knowledge about gadgets.
Tag : Android, China, google, motorola, Samsung, symbian,
Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile
at
11:07 PM
Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile - welcome to the blog Gadget Warrior, on this occasion we will discuss the information titled Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile as you are looking for, we have collect a lot of data to make this article so that you are satisfied with the information we convey, well please continue reading:
This is about : Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile
And this article : Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile
Article Android, Article China, Article google, Article motorola, Article Samsung, Article symbian,
This is about : Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile
And this article : Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile
Article Android, Article China, Article google, Article motorola, Article Samsung, Article symbian,
You can also see our article on:
- Quick Takes: Nokia's culture, RIM's interface, and living in the paradigm of engineers
- Nokia: An Excess of Cleverness
- Rikomagic MK22 Android TV Box - First impressions & Quick Review
- Easily Bypass FRP On Any Android Device
- The gold standard for trade secret theft (or is that the way of the world)? Robert Fortune and Chinese tea
- Book Review: Innovation & IPRs in China & USA
- Google unveils two new Nexus phones 5X and 6P
- How to find your phone through Google Search
- Google and Motorola: What the #@!*%?
- Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile
- Download Android Jelly Bean 4.2.2 stock firmware for Samsung Galaxy Win GT-I8558 smartphone
- Download Android Jelly Bean 4.2.2 stock firmware for Samsung Galaxy Core Advance GT-I8580
Articles Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile finished we discussed
A few of our information about the Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile, I hope that we submit article easy to understand
You've finished reading an article Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile and many articles about gadget in our blog this, please read it. and url link of this article is http://mallcopwarrior.blogspot.com/2010/01/google-shoots-itself-in-foot-in-mobile.html Hopefully discussion articles on could provide more knowledge about gadgets.
Tag : Android, China, google, motorola, Samsung, symbian,
Related : Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile
Samsung Galaxy J5 Price in Nigeria and Specs http://mallcopwarrior.blogspot.com .ng/2016/03/samsung-galaxy-j5-price-in-nigeria-jumia.html">Samsung Galaxy J5To buy at affordable prices with options of pay on delive ...
7 Ways to use your Android more than MobileYou cannot just do work on mobile, but also can use your android phone to use with your computer, Car stereo, your Printer, your TV and as various service and enhancemen ...
Download Android Jelly Bean 4.2.2 stock firmware for Samsung Galaxy Win GT-I8558 smartphoneDownload Android Jelly Bean 4.2.2 stock firmware for Samsung Galaxy Win GT-I8558 smartphone from here or here. Download previous firmware from http://mallcopwarrior.blo ...
Download latest Android Lollipop 5.0.2 stock firmware for Lenovo A3580 smartphoneDownload latest Android Lollipop 5.0.2 stock firmware for Lenovo A3580 smartphone from here or from here. Download another Lenovo firmware from http://mallco ...
Collection Of Samsung Stock ROMs / Firmware FilesDownload Samsung Mobile Android devices stock firmware for your device from the list below.If you use a Samsung MTK clone, download from below and flash using SP Flashto ...
- Book Review: Innovation & IPRs in China & USA
- Google unveils two new Nexus phones 5X and 6P
- How to find your phone through Google Search
- Google and Motorola: What the #@!*%?
- Google shoots itself in the foot in mobile
- Download Android Jelly Bean 4.2.2 stock firmware for Samsung Galaxy Win GT-I8558 smartphone
- Download Android Jelly Bean 4.2.2 stock firmware for Samsung Galaxy Core Advance GT-I8580
- Quick Takes: Nokia's culture, RIM's interface, and living in the paradigm of engineers
- Nokia: An Excess of Cleverness
- Rikomagic MK22 Android TV Box - First impressions & Quick Review
- Easily Bypass FRP On Any Android Device
- The gold standard for trade secret theft (or is that the way of the world)? Robert Fortune and Chinese tea
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment